Thanksgiving: The Root of the Tradition, the Secret to Successful Christian Living

Originally Broadcast Nov 2001The fourth Thursdaywhich the Separatists would have been very
in November is called Thanksgiving Day in thefamiliar. In their native England, days of feasting
USA. Whether you live here or not, are you goingand leisure commonly followed the harvest. Earlier
through a tough time this Thanksgiving? Asidesuch harvest festivals include ancient Greek
from all the international unrest, are you finding itThesmophoria, ancient Roman Cerealia, and the
hard to find anything to be thankful about in theJewish Sukkot.Not to imply that the 1621 feast
midst of your own life? If so, maybe thishad more in common with pagan festivals than
message will minister to you.Did you know itwith their first Christian Thanksgiving, which they
wasn't until the American Civil War (1861-1865)observed in 1623 to celebrate the now infamous
that Congress officially recognized Thanksgivingcrop-saving rainfall, after apparently skipping the
Day? Even though it all began over 200 yearsoccasion in 1622. From the Separatist perspective,
earlier in the Plymouth Colony, Massachusetts,everything fell within the bounds of faith.
1621. The Separatists (it was much later whenEVERYTHING. As Leland Ryken wrote in "Worldly
they became known as "Pilgrims"), who foundedSaints: The Puritans As They Really Were":
Plymouth Colony in 1620, ignored most holidays. In"Puritanism was impelled by the insight that all of
fact, they recognized only three: the weeklylife is God's. The Puritans lived simultaneously in
Sabbath, the Day of Humiliation and Fasting, andtwo worlds--the invisible spiritual world and the
the Day of Thanksgiving and Praise. The latterphysical world of earthly existence. For the
two were not set on the calendar but werePuritans, both worlds were equally real, and there
proclaimed in response to God's perceived favorwas no cleavage of life into sacred and secular. All
or disfavor. Colonial life was so tied to the harvestof life was sacred."In simple English, whether you
cycle that fasting days were most often called ingo to church on Thanksgiving or not, the day can
the spring, when there wasn't much to eatbe seasoned with what Puritan Richard Baxter
anyway. Feast days often accompanied thecalled "a drop of glory." For that matter, EVERY
autumn harvest. Both observances occurred onday can be seasoned in this way. As Paul and King
weekdays, usually the day of special sermonsDavid put it, "The earth is the Lord's, and
(known as Lecture Day), which was on aeverything in it" (Psalm 24:1, 1 Cor.10:26).After
Thursday in Plymouth Colony.Their first dreadfultheir first few traditional celebrations of
winter in Massachusetts had killed about half theThanksgiving, the custom of such a day soon
members of the colony. But new hope arose inspread to other colonies, becoming a time of
the summer of 1621. The settlers expected acelebrating the harvest. In 1777, the Continental
good corn harvest, despite poor crops of peas,Congress proclaimed a national day of
wheat, and barley. Thus, in early autumn,Thanksgiving after the American Revolution
governor William Bradford arranged a harvestvictory at the Battle of Saratoga, an important
festival to give thanks to God for the progressbattle which proved to the world that America
the colony had made.The festival lasted threecould stand toe-to-toe with England, who had the
days. The surviving Separatists, numbering aboutgreatest army in the world at that time. Notice it
50, feasted with 90 members of the Wampanoagwas a holiday motivated by armed conflict.
Indians who brought gifts of food as a goodwillTwelve years later, George Washington
gesture. It was not an "official" day ofproclaimed another national day of Thanksgiving in
thanksgiving. In the only surviving firsthandhonor of the ratification of the Constitution and
account of the meal, Edward Winslow described itrequested that the Congress finally establish it as
this way: "Our harvest being gotten in, ouran annual event. They declined. So, it would be
governor sent four men on fowling, that so weanother 100 years, after the nation's bloody Civil
might after a special manner rejoice togetherWar, before President Abraham Lincoln would
after we had gathered the fruit of our labors.proclaim that the last Thursday in November
They four in one day killed as much fowl as, withwould become Thanksgiving Day. That was 1865,
a little help beside, served the company almost athe year the Civil War ended. Surprisingly, it took
week. At which time, among other recreations,another 40 years, the early 1900s, before the
we exercised our arms, many of the Indianstradition really caught on. See, Lincoln's official
coming amongst us, and among the rest theirThanksgiving was sanctioned in order to bolster
greatest king Massasoit, with some ninety men,the Union's morale. Southerners boycotted the
whom for three days we entertained andnew holiday, seeing it as an attempt to impose
feasted, and they went out and killed five deer,Northern customs on their conquered land.Today,
which they brought to the plantation andThanksgiving is an annual Rockwellian event filled
bestowed upon our governor, and upon thewith football, feasting, and family that causes over
captain, and others. And although it be not always35 million Americans to "head home" for their
so plentiful as it was at this time with us, yet byfamily feasts. But that's not the historical picture
the goodness of God, we are so far from wantof this idealistic holiday. From its inception, it has
that we often wish you partakers of ourmore often been associated with adversity,
plenty."The very first Thanksgiving observance inbloody, and difficult times. Before a day of
America, two years earlier, was entirely religiousThanksgiving ever existed in a place called the
and didn't involve anything remotely resembling aUnited States, the Apostle Paul, writing from a
feast. Sorry, it wasn't the Pilgrims either. On Dec.prison cell and probably knowing that he would
4, 1619, a group of 38 English settlers arrived atsoon be killed, wrote to the Philippians, "I give
Berkeley Plantation, on the James River nearthanks to my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ."Out
what is now Charles City, Virginia. The group'sof great suffering have come many glorious
charter required that the day of arrival beexpressions of gratitude such as Paul's over the
observed yearly as a day of thanksgiving to God.centuries. One wonders, what motivates
Captain John Woodleaf held the service ofChristians to give thanks at all when a more
thanksgiving. Here is the section of the Charter ofreasonable response would seem to be bitterness
Berkley Plantation which specifies the thanksgivingand murmuring? Well, does not a new baby enter
service: "Wee ordained that the day of our shipsthe world only after a time of travail and
arrival at the place assigned for plantacon on thetransition? Does not an expectant couple prepare
land of Virginia shall be yearly and perpetuallya baby's room, and isn't the infant showered with
keept holy as a day of thanksgiving to Almightygifts, before he or she ever arrives? We
god." In accordance with this 1619 charter, thecelebrate the good things to come, in faith that
colonists most likely held service in 1620 and 1621.the good things WILL come.In the wake of the
The colony was wiped out in 1622. Thanksgivingrecent terrorist attacks, the Afghan war, the
was a private event, limited to the Berkeleyanthrax scare, the economic turmoil, and the flight
settlement.For those who see Thanksgiving as587 crash, in keeping with American tradition, we
being more of a religious holiday, where thehave all the more reason to celebrate
Separatists, or Pilgrims, were concerned, it wasn'tThanksgiving. Let's give thanks, EXPECTING new
intended to be such, though Separatist leader,life to come as a result of the turmoil that
William Bradford wrote in his diary that theirsurrounds us today.American or not, Thanksgiving
voyage across the ocean was motivated by "a- giving thanks - in the midst of dark and troubled
great hope for advancing the kingdom of Christ."times, if nothing else, is in keeping with the way
Hunting, contests of skill and strength, andof the cross ...the CHRISTIAN tradition. Give
entertainment generally have no place in religiousthanks at ALL times - even in the midst of your
observances. However, these were a part of theown trying situation.
long tradition of pagan harvest festivals, with